SILVER TONGUE
SILVER TONGUE, Hayes Theatre Co at the Hayes Theatre, to 19 December 2026. Photography by John McCrae
A new Australian musical has to be celebrated first for its creative team. The witty book is by Jacob Parker and Miranda Middleton; the composer of a range of musics is Alec Steedman. The multi-talented credits continue with Middleton also assistant director; Steedman is an on-stage violinist, also co-arranger – with Hayes co-artistic director Victoria Falconer. And her other co-director, Richard Carroll, directs. Got it?
Their achievements are amazing, as is the company of Natalie Abbott, Marty Alix, Jack Green, Lawrence Hawkins, Tana Laga’aia, Billie Palin, and Shannen Alyce Quan. Each is a multi-instrumentalist singer-actor. In short, they’re dazzling from the moment the night begins, with a rip-roaring update of Dead Man’s Chest.
That “traditional” sea shanty was actually written by Robert Louis Stevenson in Treasure Island, on which Silver Tongue is (very loosely) based. He would have been thrilled to hear a thundering drum beat as voices harmonise on:
“Fifteen men on the dead man's chest—
...Yo-ho-ho, and a bottle of rum!
Drink and the devil had done for the rest—
...Yo-ho-ho, and a bottle of rum!”

All the yo-ho-hoing amid atmospheric lighting states (Ryan McDonald), prepare us for Hailley Hunt’s splendid set. At first suggesting ye olde disreputable pub, then the good ship Hispaniola whose sails, rigging and hawsers frame the action. And the action is non-stop. It centres around sexy Silver Tongue (Billie Palin), a charismatic lady pirate whose name echoes Treasure Island’s Long John Silver.
And for anyone whose nose wrinkles at the gender flip and lesbian mischief, remember that 1700s seafarers Anne Bonny and Mary Read also terrorised the Caribbean. That the venerable Greenwich Maritime Museum describes them as “firm friends” and “close companions” pretty much confirms they were on the same course as Silver Tongue – whose name has less to do with articulacy and more that she’s extra good at mouth music.
Meanwhile, although Squire Trelawney (a gloriously incompetent Jack Green), his friend Dr Livesey (actually, a doctor of musicology, offers Shannen Alyce Quan to deaf ears), cabin boy Jim (golden-voiced Marty Alix), and Peg the Parrot (Victoria Falconer, who any aviculturist would covet) are drawn from Stevenson’s 1883 classic, this production’s Hispaniola veers quickly onto a new course. While also nicking The Treasure Map and the destination of Skeleton Island, it quickly leaves the novel behind.
Silver takes young Jim under her wing, which is as well as Trelawney – now a foppish wannabe captain – would have the Hispaniola fathoms deep in the briny if left to his own devices. Largely, it’s left to Dick, who would rather be called Richard (lovestruck and lovelorn Natalie Abbott), and Hands (Tana Laga’aia, whose mitts are rarely off one musical instrument or another) to maintain some kind of sense and course for the island. They have their hands full.

Also prominent, although not strictly visible, is costume designer Sam Hernandez, whose romantic if grubby and flea-ridden swashes and buckles beautifully summon the 1700s. Choreographer Chiara Assetta brings drollery to the shanties so necessary in warding off scurvy – along with a basket of lemons. And no pirate ship could set sail without a fight director (Tim Dashwood) who demonstrates, inter alia, what to do with the pointy end of a violin bow.
Genre- and gender-bending are the order of the voyage. There are shoals of fabulously lame gags of the pantomime variety, and much else going on that’s clever and silly and hugely entertaining. The performances are sharp and clear, from Silver’s hardy-har twinkle to Peg the Parrot’s shed feathers (she also plays a mean accordion, for heaven’s sakes).
Inventiveness and imagination infect every corner of the stage along with Richard Carroll’s joy of conjuring up a show that’s both profoundly silly and deeply trivial. The company is a delight, and not a foot is put wrong in the 100-minute voyage. No parrots were harmed in the making of this musical – 100% recommended.